Beer Review: All Things Pumpkin

With harvest season over, there isn't necessarily a lot for winemakers big or small to do in late October. We're watching wine sit in carboys, waiting for a little clarification or secondary fermentation before bottling. Fortunately, it also happens to be one of the finest times of the year for craft brewing: pumpkin ale season. Burdell Cellars is going to shift gears for a bit and talk beer.

Harpoon (Boston, MA) Pumpkin Cider is not strictly a beer, but it's a delicious pumpkin-flavored beverage that deserves a mention. I had this way back at the beginning of pumpkin-ale season, over Labor Day weekend. Steph and I agreed that this pumpkin cider was better than their pumpkin beer: a delightfully acidic combination of apple and pumpkin, with the usual pumpkin spices thrown in for good measure. Since it was so much sweeter than any of the pumpkin ales, it was tough to compare it directly, but Harpoon Pumpkin Cider is a great alternative to pumpkin beer for those who don't like beer (or addition for those who do). 4.8% ABV

Shipyard (Portland, ME) Pumpkinhead is tough not to think of as the "little brother" to Smashed Pumpkin (see below). It's fascinating to see two different takes on pumpkin ale from the same brewer, and it's clear that Pumpkinhead is the more "mass-market" version. Available in 12-oz bottles (and cans!) rather than larger bottles, it's a much lighter beer in color, flavor, and alcohol than Smashed Pumpkin. At its worst, Pumpkinhead comes across as the light beer of pumpkin beers; at best, it's a readily drinkable, unobtrusive beer that doesn't overpower with either sweetness or fruit. 5.1% ABV

Shipyard Smashed Pumpkin was one of our favorites from last fall, and it held up well this time around too. Thicker, more flavorful, and more alcoholic than Pumpkinhead, Smashed Pumpkin is loaded with cinnamon and nutmeg, and it actually tastes like pumpkin, something that's surprisingly novel for pumpkin beers. Bonus points for color: Smashed Pumpkin pours a brilliant copper, the exact shade you'd get if you put a bright candle into a dark orange pumpkin. 9.0% ABV

Samuel Adams (Boston, MA) Harvest Pumpkin Ale was another "little brother" beer, this time to the Fat Jack (also reviewed below). Harvest Pumpkin was a lot less strong or flavorful than I remember, with a nice pumpkin spice aroma but surprisingly weak spice taste. The flavor was a little reminiscent of a wheat beer, with some ester taste on the end. We all agreed this one was toward the watery end of the pumpkin beers; some of us were fine with that while others wanted something thicker. 5.7% ABV

Samuel Adams Fat Jack "Double Pumpkin," like the Smashed Pumpkin from Shipyard, was miles ahead of its six-pack relative. Fat Jack lived up to its name--it was certainly the thickest and most syrupy pumpkin beer we tried. It's creamy, almost starchy, but doesn't overwhelm with sweetness; Fat Jack boasts the same pumpkin spices in its aroma as Harvest Pumpkin but delivers more of those flavors (plus actual pumpkin) in the taste. 8.5% ABV

Uinta (Salt Late City, Utah) Punk'n Harvest Pumpkin Ale was yet another "two takes on the same beer" concept, and for a third time, the larger-batch, less-alcoholic version was the weaker one. Punk'n smelled great, a bit like a slice of pumpkin pie, but the aroma was the best part. The flavor started weak and watery and built to oddly sticky, with not nearly enough middle ground. It's brewed with organic ingredients, which is pretty cool if that's an important consideration for your beer enjoyment. 4.0 % ABV

Uinta Oak Jacked Imperial Pumpkin was easily the most complex, intriguing beer we tasted. "Imperial" is a term that gets thrown around an awful lot in beer--it usually indicates a high alcohol content, but it should also imply a certain richness and complexity. Oak Jacked Imperial Pumpkin did not disappoint in that regard--it had the depth of flavor (and alcohol content!) of an imperial stout, and the oak provided a nice heat and roasted character. A few people thought the oak overwhelmed the pumpkin, but for how ambitious this beer is, the balance was remarkably good. Given its price point, it needed to be one of the best beers we tasted, and it completely delivered. 10.3% ABV

Sacia Brewing Company (Berkeley, CA) Pumpkin was the product of my friend Eric's home-brewing operation, and it was quite credible. Eric agreed that it could have used more pumpkin flavor, but to paraphrase him, you use twice as much pumpkin as you think you should and get half the pumpkin flavor that you think you will. The base beer had a fantastic flavor to it somewhere along the lines of a pale ale, so the lack of pumpkin didn't bother us too much. Roughly 6% ABV

Kennebunkport Brewing Company (Kennebunkport, ME) Pumpkin Ale was by far the cheapest of all the pumpkin beers we tried, and it was a bit polarizing, depending on whether you wanted your beer to taste exactly like pumpkin pie rather than beer. Probably the sweetest of these beers, it was actually impressive how much like pie this beer tasted, and though its lack of alcohol or either hoppy or malty character might be off-putting for some beer aficionados, it's an incredibly inexpensive brew that tastes like a fall dessert beer. 4.7% ABV

Hermitage Brewing Company (San Jose, CA) Fruit Crate Pumpkin Ale was distinctly different from basically every pumpkin ale we had: there was no pumpkin spice, not even cinnamon! It wasn't deliberately styled as a hoppy beer, but it was so bitter compared to the rest of the pumpkin ale scene that it seemed almost like an IPA by comparison. The result was a beer that tasted more like squash than pumpkin pie, which might not be unpleasant under certain circumstances but is definitely unexpected. 9.0% ABV